At times, healthcare worker Lorna Grinnell-Moore gets the phone slammed down on her. Often, she must hear to some rather bizarre misinformation and, in a particular instance, she remembers being shouted at.
"You will inevitably encounter individuals like those, who refuse to listen, and you feel you've failed."
But this is all part of the routine duties for Lorna. She's been calling households whose kids are overdue for measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccinations with the aim of encouraging them to get immunised. Low vaccination rates mean the disease has been able to spread in the city, predominantly in children below the age of ten.
A Forward-Looking Approach
Lorna has prior experience - she was part of a team of health service staff that completed thousands of telephone contacts in just three months after a surge in measles cases in late 2023 involved many pediatric cases. Just these phone calls led nearly 1,000 once reluctant guardians and adolescents to opt for vaccination.
Within a London borough, which is in the midst of a measles surge, health leaders are studying strategies from Birmingham for ways to get a grip on it. Five dozen cases have been identified in the current year, predominantly affecting small children, some of whom have been hospitalized.
Leveraging Veteran Staff
In the 2023 Birmingham incident, some ex-healthcare workers were returned to service, like they had been. This time though, as opposed to vaccinating people, they were being deployed to persuade people to have them.
The team was tasked with making repeated calls to parents and patients under twenty-five years old to talk about their hesitancy obtaining the jab against a disease that can have grave complications - including meningitis, blindness and, on rare occasions, death.
Now, Lorna, the clinical lead for immunization services, and a team of nurses have been enlisted to restart the phone campaign as infections are increasing again.
The Art of Persuasion
This is challenging work. It takes a certain kind of approach which entails careful hearing and attempting to comprehend the individual on the line.
"When I understand their perspective, I can then answer their questions," says Lorna. "Occasionally they are receptive, and sometimes they say they don't want to hear more."
"This isn't a matter of becoming an authoritarian figure."
If people are prepared to continue the conversation, Lorna feels she can then address their apprehensions or doubts about the vaccine and assist in alleviating them.
Guidelines and Assistance
A policy limits calls to three attempts. Another rule avoids leaving voicemails due to potential confusion. Team members proficient in a variety of languages, like French, Italian, Arabic, or Urdu, can assist in outreach when the primary language isn't English.
In addition to the call initiative, the collaborative outbreak team simultaneously operates an information campaign and works with local community groups.
Clear Outcomes
The work across the city has had a significant effect. During 2024, thousands of additional immunizations were carried out – and the total number of jabs was 20 percent greater than the previous year.
Notably, there had been reduced immunization rates among certain ethnic groups, such as Roma, Eastern European, South Asian, and Black communities.
Communication obstacles were tackled by boosting the information available in a range of languages, featuring scannable QR codes connected to video content detailing the advantages, in conjunction with conventional public signage.
GP Practices Innovate
Several general practitioner practices have also begun undertaking their own outreach initiatives. One of those is Hall Green Health, which has gone further by offering GP appointments to uncertain guardians so they can discuss their concerns in person with a GP.
"I think we have become complacent about the genuine dangers of measles," explains Dr. Sonia Ashraf.
She notes there exist several elements that lead to reluctance. The fact MMR contains pork gelatine is one thing they see, yet this can be simply addressed by offering the version of the jab that is gelatine-free.
Debunked studies from the 1990s linking the MMR vaccine to autism also gets brought up, while some parents also worry about the number of routine vaccines offered to children. By the age of four, they will have been offered immunization on half a dozen occasions.
"Many families ask the necessity for numerous vaccines or feel their offspring can naturally fight off these diseases," adds Ashraf. "We dedicate time to presenting the facts with them – falsehoods are prevalent out there."
Funding Challenges and Future Outlook
The proactive calling system has since been offered to other GP practices. Yet, owing to financial constraints, it is something that can only be done on a limited basis. Recently, uptake figures dropped back to earlier, lower levels, leaving the city still well below the 95% threshold needed for herd immunity.
Even with periodic rises in infection, there has been nothing like the number of cases that were seen in the past outbreak, when reported infections topped half a thousand.
A public health lead, says the outreach approach "works very well" but "not a perfect solution" and needs to be paired with additional measures. In an ideal scenario, he notes it would be implemented more broadly but further investment is needed.
Current funding for the calling system runs until late March.
Countrywide Challenges
This strategy isn't unique to implement this method. A number of other places have undertaken analogous programs.
But shifting the dial nationally has been challenging. Right now, under 85 percent of children have had both required shots by the age of five.
"It's a real challenge," notes a specialist. "The causes of vaccine hesitancy are complicated and diverse. One thing that often gets overlooked is accessibility. For